Where Every Meal
Tells a Story
Authentic Italian cuisine crafted with passion — gourmet pizza, fresh pasta, seafood dinners, and full-service catering in Middletown, NY.
💰 $5 Off Any Order of $25 or More — Online Only
Claim Deal →Full-Service Italian Restaurant
Far More Than Just Pizza
From brick-oven pies to elegant seafood dinners — our kitchen brings the whole of Italy to Middletown.
Our Kitchen
Featured Dishes
Save 15%
On Every Online Order
Order through Slice and automatically get 15% off your entire order — every time, no coupon needed.
For Your Special Events
Full-Service
Catering
From intimate family gatherings to large corporate events — our catering team delivers the authentic Italian experience to your venue. Pasta trays, chicken classics, appetizer spreads, and more, all serving approximately 25 guests.
- Pasta Trays
- Chicken & Veal
- Antipasto Spreads
- Fresh Salads
- Stromboli Platters
- Vegetarian Options
Our Story
Three Brothers. One Passion.
Authentic Italian Food.
Born from a love of Italian cooking and a desire to bring traditional flavors to the Hudson Valley, 3 Brothers Pizza has become a cornerstone of the Middletown community. Every dish is made with the same care and passion as if it were coming out of our own family kitchen.