Our Story
Built on Brotherhood.
Fueled by Flavor.
Three brothers with one dream: bring the heart of Italian cooking to the Hudson Valley. Today, that dream lives at 1291 Dolsontown Road in Middletown, NY.
How It Started
More Than a Pizzeria
3 Brothers Pizza was born from a simple truth: that the best meals are shared ones. Three brothers — raised on their grandmother's Sunday gravy and the warm smell of dough rising in the kitchen — decided to bring that experience to Middletown, NY.
What started as a neighborhood pizza shop has grown into a full-service Italian restaurant serving everything from hand-crafted gourmet pies to elegant seafood dinners, fresh pasta, chicken & veal specialties, and a full-service catering operation.
Every dish that leaves our kitchen carries the same intention: make it as if you were cooking for someone you love.
“Every dish is made with love.”
What We Stand For
Our Values
Family First
Founded and run by brothers who believe that food brings people together — just like family.
Fresh Ingredients
We source fresh, quality ingredients every day. No shortcuts, no compromises.
Authentic Recipes
Traditional Italian recipes passed down through generations, made with love and precision.
Community Roots
Proudly serving the Middletown community — we're your neighbors, not just your restaurant.
📍 Address
1291 Dolsontown Rd
Middletown, NY 10940
🕐 Hours
Come Taste the Difference
Dine in, take out, or order online and save 15%.